Why you're not retaining fan engagement and what you should do about it

Are you losing your audience to the "anonymity gap"? In 2026, the primary reason for declining fan engagement is a lack of identity-driven personalization. Research shows that sports organizations currently know only 24% of their audience by name, resulting in generic experiences that Millennials—the most commercially valuable demographic—increasingly ignore. To stop the churn, you must bridge the gap between anonymous data and individual fan behavior.

In this guide, you’ll discover:

• How hyper-personalization drives long-term fan engagement
• The role of first-party data in crafting a frictionless, high-value fan experience
• What specific behavioral shifts are currently reshaping the global esports community
• How eStudios leveraged digital identity to solve their community retention challenges

In our experience working with global leagues, fan engagement is no longer a "nice-to-have" luxury; it is the core driver of modern revenue. According to the 2025-2026 WSC Sports Generational Fan Study, younger fans are the most likely to disengage entirely when content formats don’t match their specific consumption habits. This disconnect has massive financial implications. The January 2026 Dizplai Anonymous Fan Index highlights that one in three sports organizations now lose over US$1 million annually due to unmonetized anonymous fans. To retain your audience, your strategy must evolve from broad broadcasting to a documented personalization model that identifies and rewards individual fan actions in real-time.

How personalization drives fan engagement

To maximize fan engagement, organizations must move beyond generic content delivery. TL;DR: Modern fans, particularly Millennials, now ignore formats that don’t align with their specific behaviors; failing to implement data-driven personalization leads to significant revenue loss and audience churn. As Tobias, the CEO of eStudios, noticed: trivial details like naming a button can confuse the users and impact their overall experience as well as fan engagement.

In short, personalization is a process that enables you to tailor customer journeys and experiences to suit the individual needs and preferences of a customer. In our experience, when a digital experience anticipates user needs based on previous interactions, we see a measurable uplift in session duration and return rates.

Personalization is often mistakenly equated with customization. Unlike personalization, customization happens by the user's actions. In those cases, the users select their preferences. On the other hand, personalization stems from the system itself. Both can enhance a user’s experience, but only when carefully implemented.

While you may think of personalization as a nice-to-have luxury, 2026 research shows its fundamental impact on retention. According to the 2025-2026 WSC Sports Generational Fan Study, Millennials—the most commercially valuable audience—are the most likely to disengage when content feels irrelevant, proving that static experiences are the primary driver of audience attrition.

The financial stakes are equally high. The Dizplai Anonymous Fan Index (January 2026) reveals that sports organizations know only 24% of their audience by name on average, leading one in three to lose over US$1 million annually in revenue from unmonetized "anonymous fans." This underscores the urgent need for a documented data strategy to boost fan engagement.

Furthermore, the shift toward data is being driven by commercial partnerships. Currently, 87% of sports organizations face moderate to high pressure from sponsors to deliver measurable fan engagement data, as brands now demand granular personalization metrics before committing to long-term renewals (Dizplai Anonymous Fan Index, 2026).

The success of major streaming platforms highlights a key principle for fan engagement: using first-party data to understand and anticipate user needs is the only way to remain relevant in a crowded digital marketplace.

The role of data in personalization

To maximize fan engagement, data-driven personalization is no longer a luxury; it is the primary engine of revenue. TL;DR: Modern audiences, particularly Millennials, will ignore formats that don’t align with their specific behaviors. According to the 2025-2026 WSC Sports Generational Fan Study, irrelevant content is the leading cause of digital churn. By converting anonymous visitors into known, logged-in users, organizations can recover the average US$1 million in annual revenue currently lost to unmonetized fan data.

In our experience, data is the key to understanding your users and sustaining long-term fan engagement. It all starts with moving beyond basic demographics to knowing exactly who your fans are through their digital fingerprints. Once you analyze the real-time behaviors of your users, you can use that information to better meet their needs and even predict which specific content or offers they might want at a particular touchpoint before they even ask for it.

When deciding which data to use for personalization, you need to keep three critical factors in mind. First, you need to use genuine, first-party data. Because every fan is different, your system should learn user preferences along the way rather than relying on static profiles. While general industry data might be useful for an initial launch, it is insufficient to meet 2026 expectations where 87% of sports organizations face intense pressure from sponsors to deliver precise, measurable fan engagement metrics.

Secondly, you have to use data from all customer touchpoints. This allows you to analyze the entire customer journey from end-to-end, from social media interactions to in-app purchases. In our experience, the more interactions they have, the more tailored the experience will be. Fragmented data leads to fragmented experiences, which is why a unified data strategy is essential for retention.

Finally, you need to ensure the data is fit-for-purpose. Data privacy has evolved into a cornerstone of the user experience. Balancing both personalization and data privacy is a challenge that research firm Gartner still defines as “The privacy paradox.” With only 24% of the average sports audience known by name and contact in 2026, the organizations that win are those that provide enough value to encourage fans to share their data willingly.

Penny Gillespie, VP Analyst @ Gartner - "Organizations that combine identity data with behavioral data will outpace those that don’t. The key is to bring value to customers and keep data use in context while respecting the evolving privacy landscape of 2026."

Different behaviors in the esports fan community: The key to retaining fan engagement

TL;DR: Effectively retaining fan engagement in 2026 requires moving beyond a one-size-fits-all approach. Recent data shows that Millennials and Gen Z disengage immediately when content feels irrelevant to their specific gaming subculture. By shifting from "anonymous fans" to known, data-rich profiles, organizations can recapture the US$1 million+ in annual revenue currently lost to fragmented audience strategies.

In 2026, the esports ecosystem has matured far beyond a niche hobby into a primary entertainment pillar. However, the diversity of the landscape means there is no single "esports fan." You have sports simulation enthusiasts in FIFA or NBA 2K, tactical experts in first-person shooters like CS:GO, and high-intensity players in MOBAs like League of Legends or Battle Royale titles like Fortnite. Each demographic demands a unique experience and displays vastly different digital behaviors.

This fragmentation in gaming preferences requires a nuanced approach to retaining fan engagement. In our experience working with competitive platforms, we have seen that engagement rates can drop by up to 40% when a CS:GO fan is served content designed for a mobile-first Clash Royale player. Specificity is no longer a luxury; it is a retention requirement.

Tobias Egartner, CEO @ eStudios - "With GameTurnier the biggest community is in FIFA. Each gaming community has different behaviors. Before StriveCloud we had lots of complaints from the players. We needed a platform for FIFA behavior."

While the industry is often viewed as a monolith, research from the 2025-2026 WSC Sports Generational Fan Study highlights that fans now ignore formats that don’t match their specific gameplay behavior. Millennials—the most commercially valuable audience—are the most likely to disengage when content feels irrelevant. Furthermore, the 2026 Dizplai Anonymous Fan Index found that sports organizations only know 24% of their audience by name. This lack of data makes personalization impossible, leading one in three organizations to lose over US$1 million annually from unmonetized "anonymous" interactions.

Unlike traditional sports, fan loyalty in 2026 is increasingly fluid, often tied to individual streamers or specific game metas rather than a legacy team brand. Influencers bridge the gap between virtual and real-life sports; for example, FIFA fans prioritize content from real-world footballers and associated lifestyle brands. To succeed in retaining fan engagement, your strategy must be tailored to the specific social platforms and community hubs—be it Discord, Twitch, or TikTok—where each specific game community actually lives.

How eStudios solved the challenge of esports fan engagement through a personalized experience

TL;DR: To sustain esports fan engagement, platforms must transition from "anonymous" broadcasting to personalized, data-driven interactions. In our experience, failing to bridge this gap leads to immediate disengagement, particularly among Millennials—the most commercially valuable audience—who now demand content tailored to their specific behaviors. eStudios achieved this by leveraging a gamified, white-label solution to turn a frustrated community into a high-growth asset.

eStudios is a 360-degree Swiss esports startup focused on every aspect a brand needs to enter the gaming space. They also own GameTurnier, the largest gaming tournament platform in Switzerland. However, they faced a common industry hurdle: according to the Dizplai Anonymous Fan Index (January 2026), sports organizations typically know only 24% of their audience by name, leading to significant revenue leakage.

After testing several fan engagement technologies on the gaming tournament platform, they noticed friction within the FIFA community. User complaints revealed that a generic experience was driving players away. This broken UX didn't just frustrate gamers; it made it impossible for eStudios to deliver the measurable esports fan engagement data that 87% of sponsors now demand as a prerequisite for investment.

First, the platform needed a behavior-driven approach for designing a gamified user experience that lifts esports fan engagement. They required a system that could anticipate user needs and provide the 1-to-1 personalization that 2026 fans expect.

Furthermore, they needed a platform that works for multiple campaigns without requiring a total rebuild for every new brand partner.

That’s where StriveCloud comes in! StriveCloud’s white-label solution allowed eStudios to set up new platforms for their client portfolio in no time. Additionally, gamification experts helped analyze FIFA player behavior to create a frictionless experience. This is critical as the 2025-2026 WSC Sports Generational Fan Study highlights that irrelevant content is the primary driver for audience churn in the digital age.

The new GameTurnier platform provides a clear overview for users, streamlining the process of finding and joining competitions while capturing vital first-party data.

Drilling down into a specific tournament page, the design focuses on a frictionless experience, which was a key factor in improving community satisfaction and meeting modern esports fan engagement benchmarks.

Tobias Egartner, CEO @ eStudios - "We are really good at organizing FIFA competitions. StriveCloud is really good at making the platform work for the community."

The new platform launch was met with immediate acclaim, and in Tobias’ own words: “It was one of the best launches ever.”

The results were astonishing. By moving away from an "anonymous fan" model—which costs one in three organizations over US$1 million annually—Tobias and his team were able to build lucrative new partnerships with brands. The platform shift doubled their user growth and acquisition targets, securing over 4,000 hours of eyeball time in just two months with 600 weekly played competitions.

Nevertheless, they don’t plan to stop here. There is an even bigger opportunity to use StriveCloud in other campaigns to continue scaling their esports fan engagement strategy...

Discover how you can build a more engaging and active community platform with the right tools.

Read how you can engage users on your own community platform!